The Influential Advisor Podcast
The Authority Marketing Platform for Financial Advisors. Built for advisors who want to be known for what they're already great at.
Influential Advisor Media helps financial advisors build visibility, attract better clients, and grow through authority rather than cold outreach. If you've spent years developing real expertise and you're frustrated that the right people don't know you exist, this podcast is for you.
Influential Advisor Media was founded by Paul G. McManus, host of The Influential Advisor Podcast and creator of The Authority Operating System. Our team has worked with more than 1,000 financial advisors and helped them generate over $100 million in results through authority marketing.
Subscribe if you're a financial advisor who is done being the best-kept secret in your market.
Learn more at influentialadvisor.com
The Influential Advisor Podcast
131: Ray Offenburger on The Retirement Paradox: Why Successful People Fail at Retirement
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Ray Offenburger, CFP®, joins Gabe McManus to talk about a problem he sees again and again in people who did everything right: they saved for 40 years, and now they are afraid to spend it. Ray explains how his own parents never lost a dime in 2008, yet watched the income from their "safe" CDs fall by nearly 80%, and how facing his father's long illness and his mother's Parkinson's diagnosis without a real plan moved him from a back-office analyst job into retirement planning. He walks through what he calls just-in-case paralysis, why he invests every dollar based on its job and its timeline, and how the widow's penalty can cut a surviving spouse's income while pushing her into a higher tax bracket. Ray also shares the client stories behind his book, The Retirement Paradox: Why Successful People Fail at Retirement, including a retiree who found himself standing at the refrigerator at 9 a.m. with no idea what to do with his day.
About Ray Offenburger
Ray Offenburger is a Certified Financial Planner® who specializes in retirement planning for professionals and their families. He started his career in financial analysis, reporting, and auditing, and moved to the advice side of the business after helping his parents through the 2008 financial crisis and, later, their health crises. His practice is built on a patient, collaborative approach that puts coordination ahead of consolidation and long-term relationships ahead of transactions. A graduate of Seton Hall University and a former educator, Ray lives in Ocean County, New Jersey, with his wife. He is the author of The Retirement Paradox.
What We Cover
- How 2008 cut his parents' CD income by nearly 80% even though they never lost a dime, and why that sent Ray from crunching numbers to sitting at clients' kitchen tables
- What his father's illness and his mother's Parkinson's diagnosis taught him about the difference between a balanced portfolio and an actual plan
- Just-in-case paralysis, and the client in a heat wave who needed permission to spend $600 on a hotel room
- Risk tolerance versus risk capacity, and why Ray gives every account a job and a timeline before deciding how to invest it
- The widow's penalty: how a surviving spouse can lose $24,000 of income and still move from the 12% to the 22% tax bracket, and what couples can do while both spouses are alive
- Why Social Security may be your largest retirement asset, and why you shouldn't pick your filing date because your brother-in-law did
- Toxic generosity, from open-ended support for adult children to unplanned donations, and why it's fine to let your planner be the bad guy
- The retiree at the refrigerator door, and why the people who retire best have a reason to wake up in the morning
- Coordination: the trust that did nothing because no accounts were ever moved into it, and the "diversified" accounts at five firms that all held the same investments
Resources Mentioned
- The Retirement Paradox: Why Successful People Fail at Retirement by Ray Offenburger
Connect with Ray Offenburger
- Book Website: theretirementparadoxbook.com
- LinkedIn: linkedin.com/in/ray-offenburger
When Safe Retirement Fails
SPEAKER_02Ray Offenberger's parents thought they had retirement figured out. His father retired at 65 with a pension, social security, and investments they considered safe. CDs with no stock market exposure. Then 2008 happened. While the market crashed, they didn't lose a dime. At first it felt like they had made the right decision, but interest rates collapsed too. CDs that had been paying around 5% began renewing closer to one, and the income from their investments dropped dramatically. Then Ray's father became seriously ill soon after his mother was diagnosed with Parkinson's. Suddenly Ray faced a question he couldn't answer. What was the plan if both of them needed care? They had investments. But they didn't have a plan for when life happened. That experience changed the way Ray thought about retirement and ultimately inspired his book, The Retirement Paradox. Why successful people fail at retirement. Today on the Influential Advisor Podcast, Ray shares the lessons he's learned about spending confidently, social security, taxes, risk, and purpose. And why the people who retire best don't just have enough money to sleep at night, they also have a reason to wake up in the morning. Here is Ray Offenberger.
Ray’s Story And The Trigger
SPEAKER_01Ray, welcome to the program. So good to get to talk to you today. How are you doing? Thank you. I'm glad to be here, Gabe. Ray, the first thing I wanted to ask you is could you start by telling us about your background and what led you to where you are today?
SPEAKER_00Sure. So I started my professional career as a number cruncher. Essentially, I was doing financial analysis, reporting, auditing, things along those lines. And what drove me to the advice side of the business, like many of us who do this, is something that happened with family. So let's flashback, go back to 1998 when my father turned 65 years old. He retired from his job. Retired where he had a pension, his social security, my mom had her social security. So these three income sources were paying all of the bills. They felt comfortable with that. On the investment side, they were extremely conservative. All of their investments were in safe, fixed vehicles like CDs, no market exposure whatsoever, no money in the stock market. Right. So you fast forward now about 10 years, it's 2007, 2008, the great financial crisis happens. Market drops 35, 40 percent. My parents, however, breathe a sigh of relief and have what they think is an I told you so moment because they didn't lose a dime. Right. None of their money was in the market, it's all in these safe vehicles. But what happened to interest rates in 2008? They dropped significantly. So now these CDs start coming up for renewal. Yeah. They start maturing, and what was paying them 5%, they're lucky if they can get one. Right. So while the value of their investment accounts didn't change at all, the income that the investments were generating is now down nearly 80%. So my parents start to panic a little bit, get frustrated, angry, because it's 10 years into retirement and they feel like the rules of the game are changing. Right. So as I was helping them get through this, I realized there was a lot more I could be doing for people by sitting with them at their kitchen tables or meeting with them in my office. There was a lot more I could be doing this way than I was when I was sitting in a back office crunching numbers.
SPEAKER_01Yes.
SPEAKER_00So I became a financial advisor focusing on asset management, wealth advice, helping my parents and the clients that I was adding, building well-balanced, diversified portfolios. Now we're not done here. Let's fast forward now a couple of years. My father gets sick. Looks like it's going to be a long-term event. My parents don't have any long-term care insurance. So we're going to be self-paying. And now we need to figure out how much help can we afford for mom who's become dad's primary caregiver? What if dad needs to go into a home or some kind of facility? How much can we afford? Where are we going to get that money from? A few months after this, my mom's diagnosed with Parkinson's. Not an uncommon story today. So now we have a whole new set of questions. Well, what if mom needs help too? What if mom needs to go into a home? Here's something we never thought of. What if mom goes first? You're their financial advisor, Ray. What's the plan? And we didn't have one. We thought we had a plan, but all we had was a well-diversified, balanced portfolio, but we had no plan for what we were going to do when life happens. And we couldn't answer these questions as they were going on. Yeah. And it was when this happened that I realized there was a lot more that I needed to be doing for my clients. And that was when I went and earned my certified financial planner designation and became a financial planner focusing on retirement planning.
SPEAKER_01Ray, it's incredible that you took those experiences, those lessons learned, and then got that CFP so that you could help other people to make decisions along the way that would benefit and bless them in ways that you could help them to have better lives. So I think that's an incredible move. And then you recently, Ray, have written a book to share these lessons with people. Can you tell me the name of the book? And can you tell me about who that's intended to help?
SPEAKER_00Sure. So the book is called The Retirement Paradox: Why Successful People Fail at Retirement. And I've spent years working with folks with families who've looked ready on the financial side to retire. And then I would meet with them six months, one, two years down the road, and retirement did not seem as enjoyable as we thought it was going to be. These people weren't relaxed. They weren't as happy as I thought they should be, and as they had expected. And this book shares many of the lessons that I've learned from these experiences in working with these families and getting ready for retirement, or who are already in retirement but are trying to overcome these challenges.
Just In Case Paralysis
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Ray, you write about something in the book called Just in Case Paralysis. And so tell me what that is and how do you see this showing up with people that have retired?
SPEAKER_00I'm going to give you a prime example of what just in case paralysis is. I had a client during an epic heat wave one summer, her air conditioning stopped working. It's going to take her about two to three days for it to get fixed. So she calls me up, informs me of the situation, lets me know what's going on. She's thinking about getting a hotel room, but it's going to cost about $200 a night. And she wanted to know did I think she should do it or should she just tough it out?
SPEAKER_01Oh, that sounds like a terrible idea to just tough it out.
SPEAKER_00But this is exactly what just in case paralysis is. We stop ourselves from spending money. That might make perfect sense to do so, but we stop ourselves just in case we need this down the road. And it's primarily because we spent the last 40 years of our lives in a saving mode. And now that we're in a retirement, we're in a spending mode. We were accumulating assets and now we can decumulate them.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. So, Ray, what'd you tell her? And did she go get the hotel?
SPEAKER_00Yes, of course she did. And she knew she should, but she was just looking to me for reassurance that it was okay to do this. And that's why, you know, we have with all of my clients, we put together a retirement spending plan, cash flow analysis that's pretty detailed. And this tells us, hey, it's okay to spend $600 on a hotel room so I don't get heat stroke. It's okay. We can take that Alaskan cruise now rather than having to put this off for 10 years and hope that we're physically able to still do it.
SPEAKER_01So once she called you and asked you, you looked at the numbers and said it's going to be okay, then that allows her to spend that money and to feel comfortable about it.
SPEAKER_00And we had already looked at the numbers several times before this. So it wasn't as if we had to look at them again. It was more just me reminding her, hey, remember we looked at this and it it's $600 is okay. And and honestly, I I mean, half kiddingly, I even said to her, I said, you know, I don't think I've ever heard of anybody on their deathbed who's regretted spending six hundred dollars on a hotel room so they didn't, you know, have to endure a hundred plus degree days in their house.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's a smart way to spend your money, for sure. Yeah, exactly.
Tolerance Versus Capacity
SPEAKER_01Ray, what's the difference between risk tolerance and risk capacity? And tell me about why that matters.
SPEAKER_00Okay. So risk tolerance is our personal comfort with risk. It's how much risk we are willing or able to tolerate. This is more of an emotional aspect. However, risk capacity is based on I have these assets. This is their job, this is what I'm going to be using them for, and how much risk can they take based on that information? So it's a more informed decision. Here's an example. Have clients, they have $300,000 in an investment account. $150,000 of it is meant to be spent in the next two years. They want to buy an RV and start traveling the country, visiting national parks. Now, the clients themselves, they have a very high risk tolerance. They're comfortable being in the market, weathering the volatility, riding the highs and lows. However, these assets, this $150,000 that has been targeted and earmarked to be used in the next two years, while they have a high tolerance for risk, the capacity for risk on these assets, because of the time horizon, is very low, and it needs to be invested based on the asset's capacity for risk, not the owner's tolerance for risk. Right. And let's say that other $150,000 that they had is meant for their grandchildren's college education, and their grandchildren are five, three, and two years old. So now we're talking about we've got 10 plus years before they're going to college. So now this money, because of that timeline, has a high risk capacity.
SPEAKER_01Right. And so how do you determine the first when somebody comes and sits in front of you? How are you thinking about helping them to understand their risk tolerance?
SPEAKER_00Right. So honestly, we're going to talk very briefly about risk tolerance and we're going to focus on risk risk capacity. So I'm going to share a story similar to this and say what we are going to do is we are going to take every asset that you have, identify its job and its timeline. And based on that capacity for risk, we are going to invest it accordingly. We never want to take on any unnecessary risk. Yes. So that essentially creates our risk tolerance right there. But the other thing is with capacity, as we were talking about those grandchildren, as they get closer to college, what happens? The capacity for risk starts to change with these assets as they get closer to the time that they're going to do their job. Yeah. Capacity for risk changes over time. Tolerance doesn't always do that.
The Widow’s Penalty And Taxes
SPEAKER_00I see.
SPEAKER_01Ray, you write about something in the book that I don't even like that this is a thing, but it's the widow's penalty. So can you tell me what that is and why that exists and how that plays out in people's lives?
SPEAKER_00Sure. So the widow's penalty essentially gives a name to how the federal government treats married couples a lot better on the tax side than they do single individuals. So what happens when one spouse passes away, the surviving spouse, in most instances, a year later, is now going to be filing as a single taxpayer when previously they were probably filing married jointly. Yes. So let's take a married couple. Let's say they're both 75 years old. Husband's collecting Social Security of $3,000 a month. The wife's Social Security is $2,000. And they have a pension that's paying another $3,000 a month. So they have $8,000 of monthly income coming in. Plus, they have some traditional IRAs that have required distributions, required minimum distributions, RMDs that are equating to $20,000 a year. So when we add the RMDs and that monthly income, their annual income is $116,000, and that puts them in the 12% tax bracket. The husband passes away. What happens? The wife keeps the higher of the two Social Securities. So the $3,000 monthly Social Security benefit stays, the $2,000 falls off. The pension was a joint life pension, so that stays. So their income now has gone from $8,000 a month to $6,000 a month. They've lost $2,000 of monthly income. Now the traditional IRAs are still there, so she still needs to be taking her RMDs. That $20,000 still comes out. Their income has essentially dropped from $116,000 to $92,000. She's lost $24,000 in income. Yet because she's now filing as a single taxpayer, her tax bracket has gone from 12% when she was married to 22% now that she's single. Significant increase. And here's what's going to happen what I see happen most of the time. Yeah. She starts cutting back because things are a little tighter. Maybe she doesn't travel as much. Maybe she's not going to visit the grandkids as frequently. Maybe she's not going on the trips with her friends. Or she says to herself, you know what? I like my lifestyle. I'm going to keep spending. I'm going to keep doing what I'm doing. I've got plenty of money in these IRAs that I'm going to start pulling from. So she starts making additional withdrawals on top of the RMDs. What happens? They're all taxable. So now her tax bill has gone up. Her income has dropped. Her tax bill has gone up. That's exactly what the widow's penalty is.
SPEAKER_01And this is at exactly the time when she probably needs the support of being able to go see grandkids and having lunches with friends because she's grieving or the spouse is grieving their lost spouse and needing some of that emotional support. And to face that, Ray, what do you do to help set it up where that's not going to impact a spouse when that takes place in their life?
SPEAKER_00The best time to prepare for the widow's penalty is before anyone is a widow or widower. So we need to be planning for this years in advance. It's going to be making tax-efficient withdrawals while both spouses are here. Again, we've got RMDs. The M refers to the minimum. This is the minimum amount you have to take out, but it doesn't mean you shouldn't take out more. There could be times where it might make sense to pull an additional, in this case, she could have maybe pulled an additional $10,000 out while they were both still here, not change their tax bracket. Yeah. And then reduce her tax bill in the future. There could be, you know, Roth conversions is something that we would want to explore, of course, with a tax professional involved. But there are things that you could be doing when both spouses are here to ensure or to help the surviving spouse be prevent them from going into a higher tax bracket.
SPEAKER_01Good. I like that there's at least things that can be done proactively to make sure that's not going to affect them as much when that time happens.
Social Security As A Real Asset
SPEAKER_01Okay, I want to ask you about Social Security, Ray. Tell me about why this is one of the most important financial decisions that a retiree is making and what's missing when people just pick a date that they're going to take it.
SPEAKER_00Sure. So Social Security is going to be many people's largest retirement asset, but we don't usually see it that way. Let's take someone, they have a monthly Social Security benefit of $3,300. That equates to $40,000 a year. Over a 25-year period, that's a million dollars. However, we don't see that Social Security benefit as a million dollar asset. We just see the monthly benefit of $3,300. If we had a million dollars in a retirement account, we would be doing research. We would be exploring our options. We would be trying to make an informed and rational decision as to how to invest it. But when it comes to Social Security, too often we're making it an emotional decision. I don't trust the government. This is my money. I'm getting it now. I'm getting it while I can.
SPEAKER_01These are all the thoughts that come to all of us, right?
SPEAKER_00I mean, yeah, we all have them. Emotions are driving the decision, not a well-thought-out plan. Even worse, I've seen people choose their start date based on what was best for somebody else. My brother-in-law filed when he was 65, so I'm going to do the same. My neighbor filed when they were 70. They told me I should do that, so I'm going to do that.
SPEAKER_01That was my plan. My dad took it at 62, so I'm going to take it at 62.
SPEAKER_00That's not what I should do. That was in your dad's best interest, so you need to do what was what's in your best interest. And so there needs to be some thought and analysis and preparation going into this. Yes. The other thing I'm going to say too is that for anybody who's married, you always need to remember you're not just filing for yourself. You could be affecting your spouse's benefit as well. So there really needs to be a lot of thought that goes into it. Thinking this out, factoring in all the options. Don't make this decision a quicker decision or spend less time on Social Security filing decision than you spend on choosing your cell phone plan.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, well said. Now, this one, I didn't even know that this could be
Toxic Generosity And Boundaries
SPEAKER_01a thing. You say you talk about toxic generosity. I thought generosity is good, Ray. So tell me what toxic generosity is and why is that costing people?
SPEAKER_00There's two ways that I see toxic generosity take effect and essentially cost people. The first is when we're being generous with family. I've seen 90-year-old widows giving their 55-year-old adult children $3,000 a month to help them pay their bills, and there's no caps, no timeline, and no conditions around this help. You're not doing yourself, nor are you doing your children any favors with open generosity like this. You could be putting yourself at risk for running out of money. You might be having to make changes to your lifestyle now because you're giving this additional money to your children. And just as importantly, at some point, you're not going to be here. And if you're creating this unconditional dependence from your children on you, you just need to think what are they going to do when you're no longer here? Yeah, that makes a lot of sense. And the second way I've seen it is for some of us in retirement, we're looking to use our assets to create an identity for ourselves. Our work no longer defines us. So we're searching for something that will, and it might be through generous donations and not necessarily donating our time, but donating our assets. I actually saw one woman, her husband had passed away, and suddenly she started making large donations to charitable organizations that she related to him. There were no plan around it, no parameters around it. I totally understood why she was doing it and it made sense to me, but we just needed to have a plan. We needed to say, this is how much we can afford without it impacting our lifestyle or our future. And let's make sure we're doing it in a tax-efficient manner as well. Which account should we be donating from? Yeah.
SPEAKER_01So, Ray, that makes a lot of sense about what toxic generosity is. When these situations come up, how do you step in to help a person to avoid these situations or to remove themselves if they've already gotten themselves in?
SPEAKER_00Right. So the first thing we need to look at is anytime we're making large donations or being generous with large amounts, no matter who it is, we need to define the impact this is going to have on us and make sure it is something that will not have a long-standing impact. So going back to the cash flow, we make sure it's going to fit within our spending plan. The other thing when it comes to family, I will often say to my clients, I understand you want to help your children. I have two boys of my own. Saying no to them, especially when they need help, is extremely difficult.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's difficult.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, I mean it's tough to say no to our kids. So feel free to make me the bad guy. And essentially what I mean by that is, you know, say to your kids, hey, I'd like to help you. Yeah. My financial planner says we just need to put some limits on this and have an end game in mind. Um, that makes the client feel a little more better because now they're not essentially making the emotional decision. They have somebody that they can force the decision on or say who's helping them make the decision. But also, I I rarely see an instance where the kids push back on this because they're saying we don't want to hurt mom and dad. We and having limits and having an end game does make sense. So it it usually just moves the conversation to a better level.
SPEAKER_01Ray, my kids are still teenagers, but can I call on you to be the bad guy when you're asking me for things? Any any any anytime you want to reach out. Perfect. That would help. I wanted to ask you, you touched on this, Ray, when we were talking about the book and why you wrote it.
Purpose After The Paycheck
SPEAKER_01But that some people, they've been looking ahead at retirement for a long time. It's gonna be amazing. They're gonna, they don't have to do anything, they don't have to get up and go through the daily grind, but then they get there and they feel lost. So can you tell me why that happens and what you do to help?
SPEAKER_00This is probably the biggest challenge I see in retirement. And the people I know who have retired the best are those who don't just have the financial security to sleep at night, but they also have a reason to wake up in the morning. I'll never forget one gentleman I was working with, met with him. It was about nine months into his retirement. We got together, we crunched the numbers, went over all the financials, everything looked great. He could not have been in a better position. There was nothing at all for him to be worrying about. And I remember I was smiling and I looked up at him, expecting him to be smiling and with a relaxed look back at me, and that wasn't there. I could tell something was on his mind. He seemed anxious, and he told me he was thinking about going back to work. And I asked him, I said, Why is that? We just looked at the numbers. You don't need to financially. And his answer to this question will stay with me forever. He mentioned how earlier in that week, it was around nine o'clock in the morning, he had just had his coffee, and he found himself standing at his refrigerator door, and he had no idea what he was going to be doing the rest of that day. And then he thought even the week and even longer time periods, and it just was not a good feeling. So we talked it out, we started discussing some of his hobbies, interests, things he might have been doing at one point that he no longer was, and he actually ended up volunteering with AARP to do tax returns for other seniors. So it gave him some purpose in life, it gave him something to do, occupied, you know, a couple of days a week, and it also added a social component to his life that might have been missing as well.
SPEAKER_01That's it's such a powerful moment, him standing there and having that realization, right? Do you think that's reflective of the way a lot of people, when they get to retirement, end up feeling a little lost too?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think too often we focus on preparing for retirement, and our main focus or all of our focus is on the financial end of things. We've got a magic number in our minds. Once I get two and a half million dollars, I'll be able to retire. And we're not asking ourselves, well, it's Tuesday afternoon at one o'clock. What am I going to be doing? And that's where this anxiety and this feeling of loss of meaning can sometimes creep in. And it's not, it's not good when that happens.
SPEAKER_01Ray, I was just planning on playing golf every day. You're telling me that that's not going to be a job.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that might not, that might not be, you know, good for seven days a week. No.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, especially the way I play. I probably would get tired of it really quickly.
Coordination That Prevents Mistakes
SPEAKER_01Ray, I wanted to ask you about coordination. Tell me what that looks like in a retirement plan. And are people generally getting this from their advisors that they're working with?
SPEAKER_00Okay. That's that's a good question. And when I talk about coordination, there's two aspects of it that I refer to. The first is amongst your professionals. So that means are your legal, tax, and financial professionals all working together. I once met with a family. Mom had passed away. Before mom had passed, she had established a trust with her attorney. Unfortunately, nobody else knew this trust got established. So no assets were moved into the trust. No account titles were changed for the trust. Trust maybe should have been named a beneficiary on certain accounts. That never happened. So mom had spent thousands of dollars to have this trust created and it didn't do a thing because after it was created, nothing happened. So that's why there needs to be coordination between these professionals. Personally, with my clients, what I like to do is I like to see their tax return every year. I like to, anytime I am making a recommendation for tax purposes, tax planning purposes, we're making sure that we run it by their tax professional, they're in agreement with the reason that we're doing it and the effect that it's going to have. And also we want to make sure that they're aware that we've done this. So when they're filing their taxes next year, they're aware that this event took place. Likewise, on the legal side of things, if I have clients that have met with their attorney, if I can be there, even better. But if not, at least let me see the updated will. Let me see the trust that was established. So this way we can make sure that all of their accounts that we're aware of are titled accordingly, that the beneficiary plan lines up with the new will and things along those lines. Yeah. The second aspect of coordination that I refer to is between our investments. I meet with many people who will have accounts with four different investment firms, five different investment firms, thinking they're diversified. And then when you actually look at the statements, they're all invested the same way because the accounts are not talking to each other. All the same stuff, just in different institutions. Exactly. And coordination doesn't mean that we have to consolidate all of these accounts. Yeah. Coordination just means we have to make sure they're talking to each other. And if this money has this job and this money has this job, that they're all aware of what each other's jobs are. Essentially, each other's accounts' jobs are and they're invested accordingly.
How To Connect And Closing
SPEAKER_01Right. That makes a lot of sense, Ray. Ray, for listeners that would like to get in touch with you or get a copy of your book, how should they do that?
SPEAKER_00So go to the website, the retirementparadoxbook.com. In the upper right corner of the site, you'll see there will be a button that you could click on to get a copy of the book. Also, our contact information is on the site as well. I encourage you if you have anything to share, any stories, anything that you think could add to this conversation or add to the book, I really appreciate hearing from new people. Let's spend 10, 15 minutes together. Shoot me an email, give us a call, and you know, always enjoy hearing from new people. Oftentimes I'm learning as much from them as they're learning from me.
SPEAKER_01Ray, I learned a lot from our conversation today. Thanks so much for taking the time. Thank you very much for having me, Gabe.